Leave grass clippings on the lawn most of the time. University of Minnesota Extension (2024) finds that leaving clippings does not contribute to increased thatch, contrary to popular belief. Purdue Extension (AY-8) reaches the same conclusion: clippings are mostly water and break down quickly. University of California IPM notes that grasscycling may slightly increase thatch buildup, but the benefits outweigh the disadvantages in most situations, and the risk is tied to grass that is too wet or too tall. In Purdue Extension’s Texas “Don’t Bag It” pilot (ID-182), participants cut average mowing time by more than 30 percent, although they mowed more often.

Bag instead when clippings run longer than about an inch, when the lawn is wet or too tall at the cut, or when the turf is heavily infested with certain leaf diseases (sources disagree on how much removal helps).

Do Clippings Cause Thatch?

University of Minnesota Extension (2024) states, contrary to popular belief, that leaving clippings on the lawn does not contribute to increased thatch. Purdue Extension (AY-8) explains why: clippings are mostly water and break down quickly.

University of California IPM takes a narrower view. Grasscycling may slightly increase thatch buildup, but the benefits outweigh the disadvantages in most situations. UC IPM ties the risk to grass that is too wet or too tall when you cut.

If the lawn already has heavy thatch, see the guide to thatch and dethatching tools.

How Much Nitrogen Clippings Return

Returned clippings recycle nutrients. The extension figures below all support that point, but they use different measures, so treat each number on its own terms rather than as a single combined rate.

Penn State Extension reports that over three years, Kentucky bluegrass clippings contained 46 to 59 percent of the nitrogen applied as fertilizer, and returning those clippings lets you reduce fertilizer applications. Colorado State University Extension states that nitrogen applications can often be reduced by 1/4 to 1/3 when clippings are returned. University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension finds that leaving clippings returns the equivalent of about 1 lb of nitrogen per 1,000 sq ft a year, equal to one normal fertilizer application. NC State Extension reports that fertilizer use can be reduced by 20 to 30 percent. University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension states that returning clippings adds up to 2.0 lb of nitrogen per 1,000 sq ft a year.

Percent of applied nitrogen, share of fertilizer, and pounds per 1,000 sq ft are different measures, so the figures can’t be added or averaged.

When to Bag Instead

Mulching is the default. Bagging is the exception for specific conditions.

University of Minnesota Extension advises that clippings of an inch or less can be left; they filter down and decompose quickly. Remove longer clippings, because they can shade or smother the grass beneath. The same source advises removal when the lawn is wet or too tall at mowing, because clippings can mat together and smother the grass. University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension adds that cutting wet turf makes clippings clump on the lawn and can be dangerous on wet slopes.

Disease is the case with a real split. University of Minnesota Extension recommends removing clippings if the lawn is heavily infested with diseases such as leaf spot, rust, or dollar spot, to help reduce disease severity. University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension disagrees in part: disease spores are present whether clippings are collected or returned, and watering, fertilization, and blade sharpness influence disease far more than returning clippings.

Mulching Mower or Side Discharge?

Purdue Extension (AY-8) recommends mulching mowers, but research suggests they break clippings down only slightly faster than side-discharge mowers on cool-season grass. Colorado State University Extension notes that side-discharge rotary mowers also spread clippings well if the lawn is mowed often enough.

If you are shopping for one, see the comparison of mulching mowers.

To shop for blades, see high-quality mulching blades.

Keep the blade sharp: Illinois Extension says dull blades rip and tear grass, leaving ragged wounds that are harder to heal.

Mowing for Clean Mulching

University of Minnesota Extension states that regular mowing greatly reduces the need to collect clippings, and you should avoid cutting more than one-third of the grass height at a time. The mowing heights guide gives the range for each grass.

Penn State Extension notes that during peak spring growth you may need to mow more than once a week. For the first cut of the year, see when to start mowing in spring.

Wet grass works against mulching. University of Minnesota Extension flags wet or overly tall turf as a matting risk. University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension flags clumping and slope safety when you cut wet turf.

If you miss a mowing, University of Missouri Extension says to cut halfway back to your usual height and finish a couple of days later.

Using Bagged Clippings

Bagged clippings are a waste stream you can use, with herbicide timing limits.

Purdue Extension (ID-182) states that clippings from lawns treated with weed killer should not be used as mulch for at least 8 weeks after the herbicide is applied. University of Wisconsin-Madison Extension advises not to use clippings as mulch in beds or gardens if herbicides were applied to the grass in the preceding 3 months. The two waiting periods differ.

Purdue Extension (ID-182) also covers composting clippings as a use for collected yard waste. For bins, see compost bins.

If your city collects yard waste, check which bags it accepts; heavy-duty paper lawn bags are one option.


  • Mulching Blades:
  • Compost Bin:
  • Lawn Bags: